The Asylum   Search Private Messages Options Blogs Images Chat Cam Portals Calendar FAQ's Join  
Asylum Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.2.8 Asylum Forums > Polėticās der Mondé > Oops! British dossier on Iraq plagiarised
  Last Thread   Next Thread
Author
Thread [new thread]    [post reply]
Smug Git
Arrogance Personified

Registered: Aug 2001
Location: Hilbert Space
Posts: 36297
Oops! British dossier on Iraq plagiarised

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/2735031.stm

Oh dear. The intelligence dossier on Iraq that was recently released by the British government turns out to have been largely lifted (including spelling mistakes) from public sources.

quote:
Downing Street has defended an intelligence dossier of evidence against Iraq after allegations that it included plagiarised material that was 12 years out of date.
The UK intelligence document released on Monday was designed to help win over sceptics by detailing Saddam Hussein's efforts to hide weapons of mass destruction.

But Channel 4 News claimed the document was largely copied from three different articles, including one written by a postgraduate student.

The programme claimed excerpts from a paper relating to the build-up to the 1991 Gulf War by Californian student Ibrahim al-Marashi were lifted into the intelligence document.

But a Downing Street spokesman said the dossier was "accurate" and that the government had never claimed exclusive authorship.

US praise

"The report was put together by a range of government officials," he said.

"As the report itself makes clear, it was drawn from a number of sources, including intelligence material.

"It does not identify or credit any sources, but nor does it claim any exclusivity of authorship.

"We consider the text as published to be accurate."

The UK document received praise from US Secretary of State Colin Powell this week as he outlined his country's case against Iraq.

"I would call my colleagues' attention to the fine paper that United Kingdom distributed yesterday, which describes in exquisite detail Iraqi deception activities," Mr Powell told the UN security council.

Channel 4 News highlighted examples of the alleged plagiarism, including a suggestion in the dossier that Iraq was "supporting terrorist organisations in hostile regimes".

This compared to the weaker, political context in the original which read "aiding opposition groups in hostile regimes."

Errors copied

Dr Rangwala, lecturer in politics at Cambridge University, told the programme that the British Government's dossier was 19 pages long, but most of pages 6 to 16 were copied directly from the student's document word for word.

"Even the grammatical errors and typographical mistakes," he said.

"The information he was using is 12 years old and he acknowledges this in his article.

"The British Government, when it transplants that information into its own dossier, does not make that acknowledgement."

Shadow defence secretary Bernard Jenkin said the Tories were deeply concerned by the programme's report.

"The government's reaction to the Channel 4 News report utterly fails to explain, deny or excuse the allegations made in it," he said.

"This document has been cited by the prime minister and Colin Powell as the basis for a possible war. Who is responsible for such an incredible failure of judgment?"

Cosmetic changes

Liberal Democrat foreign affairs spokesman Menzies Campbell added: "This is the intelligence equivalent of being caught stealing the spoons.

"The dossier may not amount to much but this is a considerable embarrassment for a government trying still to make a case for war."

Mr Al-Marashi told the BBC Two Newsnight programme the government document was still accurate despite "a few minor cosmetic changes".

"The only inaccuracies in the UK document were that they maybe inflated some of the numbers of these intelligence agencies.

"The primary documents I used for this article are a collection of two sets of documents, one taken from Kurdish rebels in the north of Iraq - around four million documents - as well as 300,000 documents left by Iraqi security services in Kuwait."


It is going to look good on that guy's CV, though; 'My work was cribbed by the British government'. Oh dear.

__________________
I want to live and I want to love
I want to catch something that I might be ashamed of

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 02-07-2003 08:20 AM
Smug Git is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Smug Git Click here to Send Smug Git a Private Message Find more posts by Smug Git Add Smug Git to your buddy list [P] Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
RiZZ
awsomeness incarnit

Registered: Jul 2000
Location: aggressivly happy
Posts: 9232

haha marvlous

__________________
RiZZ > you.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 02-07-2003 08:26 AM
RiZZ is offline Click Here to See the Profile for RiZZ Click here to Send RiZZ a Private Message Visit RiZZ's homepage! Find more posts by RiZZ Add RiZZ to your buddy list [P] Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
euphorbia
caustic milk - hybrid

Registered: Apr 2001
Location: behind the irony curtain
Posts: 19147

from what I understand the only parts used were back ground info, the actual condemning info came from intel sources. The things people are whining about are pretty much "filler".







http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/politics/2736149.stm

The UK government has been accused of "copying" parts of this week's dossier on Iraq from the work of a postgraduate student.
Here are some examples of similarities between the government dossier and the work of Ibrahim al-Marashi.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The National Security Council

Government dossier

"Headed by Saddam Hussein but usually chaired by his son Qusay Hussein, it oversees the work of all other security agencies."

Ibrahim al-Marashi's work

"Headed by Saddam, but usually chaired by Qusay, the Council includes representatives from the Office of the Presidential Palace and Iraq's five major security units.

"Although Special Security was created to serve as an agency to coordinate Iraq's competing intelligence and security services, the National Security Council serves as the supervisory body on intelligence matters."



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Directorate of General Intelligence
Government dossier

"Al-Mukhabarat is roughly divided into a department responsible for internal operations, co-ordinated through provincial offices, and another responsible for international operations, conducted from various Iraqi embassies.

Its internal activities include:

Spying within the Ba'th Party, as well as other political parties;
Suppressing Shi'a, Kurdish and other opposition
counter-espionage
targeting threatening individuals and groups inside Iraq
spying on foreign embassies in Iraq and foreigners in Iraq
maintaining an internal network of informants
Its external activities include

spying on Iraqi diplomats abroad
collecting overseas intelligence
supporting terrorist organisations in hostile regimes
conducting sabotage, subversion, and terrorist operations against neighbouring countries such as Syria and Iran
murder of opposition elements outside of Iraq
infiltrating Iraqi opposition groups abroad
providing dis-information and exploitation of Arab and other media
maintaining an international network of informants, using popular organisations as well such as the Union of Iraqi Students."
Ibrahim al-Marashi's work

"General Intelligence is roughly divided into a department responsible for internal operations, coordinated through provincial offices, and another responsible for international operations, conducted from various Iraqi embassies. Its internal activities include:


1) monitoring the Ba'th Party, as well as other political parties
2) monitoring other grass roots organizations, including youth, women and union groups
3) suppressing Shi'a, Kurdish and other opposition
4) counter-espionage
5) targeting threatening individuals and groups inside of Iraq
6) monitoring foreign embassies in Iraq
6) monitoring foreigners in Iraq
7) maintaining an internal network of informants
Its external activities include:


8) monitoring Iraqi embassies abroad;
9) collecting overseas intelligence;
10) aiding opposition groups in hostile regimes;
11) conducting sabotage, subversion, and terrorist operations against hostile neighboring countries such as Syria and Iran;
12) murder of opposition elements outside of Iraq;
13) infiltrating Iraqi opposition groups abroad;
14) providing disinformation and attempts to exploit or use Arab and other media
15) maintaining an international network of informants, using popular organizations as well such as the Union of Iraqi Students."


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Directorate of Military Intelligence

Government dossier

"These shifting appointments are part of Saddam's policy of balancing security positions.

"By constantly shifting the directors of these agencies, no one can establish a base in a security organisation for a substantial period of time. No one becomes powerful enough to challenge the President. "

Ibrahim al-Marashi's work

"These shifting appointments are part of Saddam's policy of balancing security positions between Tikritis and non-Tikritis, in the belief that the two factions would not unite to overthrow him.

"Not only that, but by constantly shifting the directors of these agencies, no one can establish a base in a security organization for a substantial period of time, that would challenge the President."



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Military Security Service

Government dossier

"The Security branch is responsible for monitoring and countering dissent within Amn, and the Military Brigade provides rapid intervention para-military capabilities - the Brigade commander was executed in August 1996 for alleged involvement in a coup attempt."

Ibrahim al-Marashi's work

"Military Security is responsible for 1) detecting and countering dissent in the Iraqi armed forces"



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Special Republican Guard

Government dossier

"Headed by Qusay Hussein, it serves as a praetorian guard, protecting Presidential sites and escorting Saddam Hussein on travels within Iraq. "

Ibrahim al-Marashi's work

"Qusay heads this unit, which provides protection for all presidential sites, including offices and personal residences, as well as escorting Saddam when he is traveling within Iraq."

__________________
taste the fucking rainbow & dont touch my junk.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 02-07-2003 04:25 PM
euphorbia is offline Click Here to See the Profile for euphorbia Click here to Send euphorbia a Private Message Visit euphorbia's homepage! Find more posts by euphorbia Add euphorbia to your buddy list [P] Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Smug Git
Arrogance Personified

Registered: Aug 2001
Location: Hilbert Space
Posts: 36297

If the government publishes a docment, in order to guide our opinions, of which 10 pages of 19 are lifted directly from soneone else's work, that is very significant. It is certainly true that they didn't lie, however.

This is causing a stir here, and I think that it is fair to say that the goverment have been caught pants down on this (I can't imagine that anyone senior knew the provenance of those ten pages). It doesn't really push the debate either way, but it is a pretty poor show. They didn't even credit the guy (you are hardly going to credit 'intelligence sources', but this stuff was public domain already).

__________________
I want to live and I want to love
I want to catch something that I might be ashamed of

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 02-08-2003 12:21 AM
Smug Git is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Smug Git Click here to Send Smug Git a Private Message Find more posts by Smug Git Add Smug Git to your buddy list [P] Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Paint CHiPs
Smartest Man in the World

Registered: Jul 2000
Location: Location Location
Posts: 26816

I sort of thought the point of the dossier and inteligence reports was to provide new information?

Am I completely off-base on that? I recognize that there would be filler and background info, but still, when these reports are hyped as providing new insights, and it turns out that half of them are plagarized from 12 year old thesis' from academia, that is surely a PR black eye, even if unfairly?

Even if it isn't a negation of anything, certainly doesn't cause me to invest much trust in the reports as a whole. May be my general knee-jerk reaction to plagarism, though, as an English major. My general rule on plagarism is that if you employ it, it's because you don't have anything original or of-value to put in its place. Which is fine if you're doing a book report and make sure to credit your sources.

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 02-08-2003 07:06 AM
Paint CHiPs is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Paint CHiPs Click here to Send Paint CHiPs a Private Message Visit Paint CHiPs's homepage! Find more posts by Paint CHiPs Add Paint CHiPs to your buddy list [P] Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
redguard
Commie Bastid

Registered: Aug 2000
Location: Cnafilornia
Posts: 406

Fuck...


I don't even have to HAVE a case in order to rest it with evidence like that floating around.


-redguard@blackvault.com

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 02-08-2003 07:50 AM
redguard is offline Click Here to See the Profile for redguard Click here to Send redguard a Private Message Find more posts by redguard Add redguard to your buddy list [P] Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Smug Git
Arrogance Personified

Registered: Aug 2001
Location: Hilbert Space
Posts: 36297

quote:
Originally posted by Paint CHiPs
May be my general knee-jerk reaction to plagarism, though, as an English major.


Plagiarism is a no-no in any academic field, in fact (the end of a career, often). I don't think that the thesis was necessarily 12 years old, but rather the information used in it was.

If it wasn't so serious, it would be hilarious.

Well, it is still hilarious.

__________________
I want to live and I want to love
I want to catch something that I might be ashamed of

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 02-08-2003 10:59 AM
Smug Git is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Smug Git Click here to Send Smug Git a Private Message Find more posts by Smug Git Add Smug Git to your buddy list [P] Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
Nutrimentia
plata o plomo

Registered: Sep 2000
Location: The Bottom of the Toyem Pole
Posts: 9604

Hilarious if it wasnt a prelude to war.

...and some people still take the government's word at face value.....

__________________
The Law of Fives is never wrong. CzEch yerself b4 joo rEck yerself. Hi-yo!

Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 02-08-2003 11:23 AM
Nutrimentia is offline Click Here to See the Profile for Nutrimentia Click here to Send Nutrimentia a Private Message Visit Nutrimentia's homepage! Find more posts by Nutrimentia Add Nutrimentia to your buddy list [P] Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
skalie
Locksmith of Lurve

Registered: Sep 2001
Location: World Citizen
Posts: 18916

From here

quote:


Tony Blair and George Bush are encountering an unexpected obstacle in their campaign for war against Iraq - their own intelligence agencies.

"You cannot just cherry-pick evidence that suits your case and ignore the rest. It is a cardinal rule of intelligence," said one aggrieved officer. "Yet that is what the PM is doing."

Last week Colin Powell made much of the presence in Iraq of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the man he identified as running an al Qaeda network from Baghdad. He drew on information from al-Zarqawi's captured deputy, but made no mention of another explosive allegation from the same detainee: that Osama bin Laden's organisation received passports and NZ$1.8m in cash from a member of the royal family in Qatar.

It is well known in US intelligence circles that the CIA director, George Tenet, is angry with the Qatari government's failure to take action. But the Gulf state would be the main US air operations base in any war on Iraq, and Washington does not want to air the inconvenient facts in public.



Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged

Old Post 02-09-2003 09:52 AM
skalie is offline Click Here to See the Profile for skalie Click here to Send skalie a Private Message Find more posts by skalie Add skalie to your buddy list [P] Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote
All times are GMT. The time now is 02:50 PM. Post New Thread    Post A Reply
  Last Thread   Next Thread
Show Printable Version | Email this Page | Subscribe to this Thread

Forum Jump:
 

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is ON
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON
 

< Contact Us - The Asylum >

Copyright © 2014- Imaginet Inc.
[Legal Notice] | [Privacy Policy] | [Site Index]